17:51:16 From Captioner-Heather Jensen to CSD Support Staff - Emily Mann (she/they)(Direct Message): Hello...can you please assign me to type and turn of autocaptions. Thank you. 18:01:04 From Maria Spanish Interpreter to Everyone: Hi, This is Maria Spanish Interpreter. Do you know who the other Spanish interpreter will be? 18:02:02 From Luisa Aldama to Everyone: Im here Spanish interpreter 18:02:45 From Ashley Schofield to Everyone: It is bright out! 18:04:09 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Reacted to "It is bright out!" with 👍🏼 18:04:28 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Replying to "It is bright out!" I live in a basement, so I have to look up... 18:05:31 From Pastor Robin Wisner to Everyone: welcome Scott 18:05:50 From Pastor Robin Wisner to Everyone: hello everyone 18:06:06 From Kala to Everyone: hello:) 18:08:16 From Natalie she/her to Everyone: Natalie she/her the COCL, lifelong Portland community member) (with a working camera for the first time since November) 18:09:44 From barb. to Everyone: Barb. Rainish community member, PCCEP groupie, member of the( BHUAC) Portland Police's Behavioral health unit advisory council.. 18:09:47 From barb. to Everyone: ..looking forward to seeing Natalie this year 18:10:07 From Kala to Everyone: Reacted to "Barb. Rainish commun…" with ❤️ 18:10:12 From Ann Campbell (she,her) to Everyone: Please introduce yourself in the chat everyone🙂 18:10:25 From Marc Poris (he/him) to Everyone: Marc Poris, he/him, Portland Copwatch 18:10:50 From Debbie Aiona to Everyone: Debbie Aiona she/her League of Women Voters of Portland 18:16:31 From Kala to Everyone: Hello everyone. Kala Franklin, she/her, community member. Sorry I missed the original introduction time, my send to had someone other than everyone. 18:20:27 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: The outreach list is in the 100's now, really reaching out to mostly the marginalized community so that we can bring them to the table, including LGBTQIA+ outreach, Sex worker advocates, D&A centers, I met with Tribal Relations today. 18:22:43 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Every Police & City Advisory group is on the outreach list. As well as each PPB task force... 18:24:49 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: If you want to make sure an agency or person is on the list, email Tia, Ashley or Leslie. 18:26:36 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Also in regards to the CESC update is we are recommending NOT to move forward on the pilot program. Due to the overwhelming community voice to not to... 18:27:42 From barb. to Everyone: once it hits council it's too late usually!! people should be signing up for public comment before council meetings on wednesday morning. there are 6 slots 18:27:57 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Reacted to "once it hits council..." with 👍🏼 18:29:05 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: We are going to the council meeting aren't we? 18:29:07 From barb. to Everyone: is a recommendation in the works on this from pccep 18:30:07 From PCCEP Portland to Everyone: Yes Barb - we will be looking at it next 18:30:07 From Ashley Schofield to Everyone: Barb, we have a recommendation ready to vote on today hopefully. 18:30:17 From barb. to Everyone: yay!! 18:30:59 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Replying to "is a recommendation ..." Yes 18:34:00 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Replying to "once it hits council..." It was my understanding that we are planning to 18:42:47 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Looking & sounding on-point so far... 18:47:07 From barb. to Everyone: please read out 18:49:43 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: I am in agreement & it matches with the townhall conversation. We also have many written & verbal quotes from the community. 18:49:59 From barb. to Everyone: great job!! 18:50:10 From Barbara Bochinski Portland Copwatch to Everyone: Sounds great! 18:51:41 From Dr. Rochelle Silver to Everyone: Good recommendation. There is a typo near the end . You have the word complied when it should be compiled 18:51:56 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Reacted to "Good recommendation...." with 👍🏼 18:54:06 From PCCEP Portland to Everyone: Thank you Rochelle! 18:55:04 From PCCEP Portland to Everyone: Do you remember where that was? 19:01:26 From Kala to Everyone: I would like to add that I wasn’t aware there was other Gun Shot Technology vendors, and during the Town Hall meeting that wasn’t discussed. 19:01:42 From Dr. Rochelle Silver to Everyone: I think it was in the last paragraph or if not there, the one above it. 19:02:59 From Kala to Everyone: I think it would be nice if PCCEP had provided this information during the town hall. 19:03:46 From barb. to Everyone: greenspaces 19:04:51 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Replying to "I would like to add ..." We talked about EAGL & that there are 4 companies up for it... I thought....?? 19:05:49 From barb. to Everyone: i agree tia. stephanie discussed it 19:06:07 From Barbara Bochinski Portland Copwatch to Everyone: I remember that there was a discussion about the other companies and a lot about environmental prevention. 19:06:18 From Kala to Everyone: Replying to "I would like to add …" No during the March 1st Town Hall for Gun Shot detection this wasn’t mentioned 19:06:26 From Stephanie Howard to Everyone: Just noting that the City is implementing most, if not all, of the recommendations that were discussed. PEMO is working to light up the City and the Safe Blocks team is doing amazing work with community to counter gun violence from a CPTED approach. There are many other preventative investments made through the Office of Violence Prevention and Community Safety Division. 19:06:39 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Replying to "I would like to add ..." ShotSpotter is who most people know of b/c they have been in the news... 19:08:07 From Natalie she/her to Everyone: Those interested in environmental criminology, I recommend reading Charles Branas study on vacant land and its effect 19:08:57 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Replying to "I would like to add ..." @Kala When we were talking about GDT, we were talking about the technology, not the companies per se. 19:09:45 From Ann Campbell (she,her) to Everyone: No. 19:11:26 From Ann Campbell (she,her) to Everyone: Criticizing the process 19:11:36 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: At least have that the FITCOG recommended it and saw their own group as "community" 19:12:49 From Celeste Carey to Everyone: our goal was to discuss gunshot detection in general, not the individual companies. some of the companies have technological differences in how they operate...eg some use microphones and cameras, some use sound wave capture. 19:14:57 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: We can be neutral with FITCOG 19:15:18 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Reacted to "our goal was to disc..." with 👏🏼 19:15:45 From Kala to Everyone: Replying to "I would like to add …" Okay, thank for the clarification 19:16:16 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Thank you Ashley for your work on this. 19:17:04 From Dr. Rochelle Silver to Everyone: If what you wrote about the FITCOG is fact and true, leave it in. 19:17:13 From PCCEP Portland to Everyone: Replying to "I would like to add ..." We did mention it in the timeline at the town hall 19:17:22 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Replying to "I would like to add ..." 👍🏼 19:17:46 From PCCEP Portland to Everyone: @Seemab and others, we will have public comment prior to a vote on this. So, soon. 19:18:24 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Replying to "I would like to add ..." Sorry Kala! 19:19:03 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: FITCOG recommended it 19:19:25 From Seemab (he/him) to Everyone: Just wanted to offer the thought that as I am also a volunteer member of the Police Accountability Commission, we should all hold the values of our thoughts and opinions, as our own commissions, even when there are critical thinking about our partner commissions in the City of Portland 19:21:14 From Natalia Ochmanek to Everyone: I am a community member and PEAC member. I approve of the recommendation language as is. It highlights the gross lack of evidence of effectiveness of the technology, and even more ineffectiveness and harm that it can do to people experiencing mental health challenges and living in the neighborhoods. With such an evidence based facade of publicity with no evidence, If there was an effective technology that was careful with implicit bias, great, let’s explore that! But the gun detection technology, as is, is not effective at solving the problem we would purchase it for, for any of the bidding technologies. Let’s implement a different solution… Like more PSR social workers and stable housing. 19:21:34 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Replying to "I would like to add ..." And I thought we were going to have more education around GDT & that didn't happen. I think a lot of us are doing our own research. 19:22:15 From Seemab (he/him) to Everyone: Our individual experiences are a partial weight of qualitative and quantitative data 19:23:04 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Pastor are you wanting to hear from FITCOG and why they recommended it? 19:24:20 From Ann Campbell (she,her) to Everyone: Let’s please let others speak 19:24:50 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: It looks factual to me. 19:25:47 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: BRB 19:26:14 From Natalie she/her to Everyone: it 19:26:17 From Natalie she/her to Everyone: soops sorry 19:27:06 From Celeste Carey to Everyone: the references to fitcog are factual, they are not derogatory. the references are necessary because the city is using the fitcog recommendation as one base for moving forward with the pilot... 19:29:33 From Pastor Robin Wisner to Everyone: Tia that would be fine if they wanted 19:29:40 From Nathan Castle to Everyone: Original recommendation: https://www.portland.gov/fitcog/documents/fitcog-shotspotter-recommendation/download 19:30:01 From Dr Elizabeth Allen to Everyone: please let us talk witheach other during break 19:30:16 From Nathan Castle to Everyone: “All regular FITCOG meetings designate time on the agenda to accept public testimony from community members. This recommendation also includes feedback, insight, and concerns brought forward by members of the community who have given public testimony in FITCOG meetings. ” 19:30:41 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Replying to "Tia that would be fi..." I thought that's what you were wanting before we moved on 19:30:44 From Stephanie Howard to Everyone: I would be happy to facilitate an opportunity for members of our different community groups to come together regularly and check in on the work of each. 19:31:35 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: I'm making dinner and leaving at 2:00 am for Boston... 19:32:01 From Pastor Robin Wisner to Everyone: Stephanie that would be wonderful 19:32:45 From Sarah Ames, she/her, Dep City Atty to Everyone: barb. you may be a PCCEP "groupie" but your ARE a volunteer member of BHUAC :-) 19:39:35 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Are we back? 19:40:00 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Hi Derek! 19:41:21 From LKMartinez to Everyone: Replying to "I would be happy to ..." I like that idea 19:41:23 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: What did you decide on FITCOG? Is it all staying? 19:45:48 From PCCEP Portland to Everyone: The recommendation passes. 7 votes yes, 2 votes no. 19:47:03 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: City Council meeting time & date? 19:47:36 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Our next mtg is April 12 though... 19:48:33 From barb. to Everyone: see my comments above! i can talk about that if it helps you reach out to me. 19:48:49 From Dr Elizabeth Allen to Everyone: Can the city spend this money regardless of our input? Can the mayor buy it before his 60 days are up? 19:49:31 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Replying to "Can the city spend t..." I think only Stephanie would know that. 19:49:38 From Ashley Schofield to Everyone: Yes, the City could vote on it before that. 19:49:54 From Ashley Schofield to Everyone: But it’s murky with the Settlement requirement to get back to us in 60 days. 19:50:58 From Ashley Schofield to Everyone: https://www.portland.gov/pccep 19:51:31 From Ashley Schofield to Everyone: https://www.portland.gov/pccep/pccep-recommendations 19:51:44 From barb. to Everyone: maybe there needs to be a way for "emergency" approval of less than 60days 19:53:37 From barb. to Everyone: is there supposed to be a response if it is not adopted 19:53:40 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Reacted to "is there supposed to..." with ❤️ 19:53:49 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Reacted to "maybe there needs to..." with ❤️ 19:54:25 From barb. to Everyone: in the PAST the mayor's person and Mary Claire often checked up and brought status reports 19:55:46 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Replying to "I would be happy to ..." What do you mean? what community groups? Advisory councils? 19:56:15 From PCCEP Portland to Everyone: All kudos to Emily! 19:56:36 From barb. to Everyone: thank you staff!! 19:57:00 From Dr Elizabeth Allen to Everyone: What about a status report on adopted recommendations? 19:57:10 From barb. to Everyone: which ones are open? 19:57:23 From Debbie Aiona to Everyone: The Seattle Community Police Commission has a very handy way of tracking their recommendations. I don’t know how hard it would be to create something similar for PCCEP, but you might want to take a look. https://www.seattle.gov/community-police-commission/our-work/recommendations-tracker 19:58:16 From Ashley Schofield to Everyone: Thanks, Debbie 19:59:00 From Dr. Rochelle Silver to Everyone: Can Ms. Howard her explain how a no-bid contract was let to a new organization staffed by ex Portland police 19:59:21 From PCCEP Portland to Everyone: Debbie, we totally agree! We've tried to figure out how to replicate it on the Portland.gov website, but it's an open question. 20:01:02 From Dr Elizabeth Allen to Everyone: rectifying anything might not be seen as consistent with a TRC 20:02:05 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Reacted to "The Seattle Communit..." with 👍🏼 20:03:35 From dan handelman he/him to Everyone: Thank you Celeste 20:03:51 From Jared Hager--US DOJ (he/him) to Everyone: Reacted to "The Seattle Communit…" with ❤️ 20:07:06 From barb. to Everyone: Reacted to "Thank you Celeste" with 👍 20:08:39 From Ann Campbell (she,her) to Everyone: Thank you Ashley!!! 20:09:13 From Seemab (he/him) to Everyone: Amen Ashley 20:09:52 From barb. to Everyone: 👍 20:09:55 From Ann Campbell (she,her) to Everyone: You go Ashley 20:10:15 From Natalia Ochmanek to Everyone: What role did City HR bureau play in the speed of sneaking the Trust Lab contract? I ask because I have been increasingly seeing BHR wield slowing and speeding up bureaucracy in a political ways. Is my concern about their role in inequitable city implementation real? 20:13:17 From barb. to Everyone: which police chief signed off on the trc recommendation? 20:13:39 From Dr. Rochelle Silver to Everyone: Again, what about Ms. Howard's responsibility here? 20:13:53 From Ashley Schofield to Everyone: Good question, Natalia. 20:13:58 From Ashley Schofield to Everyone: Stephanie can you answer that question 20:14:09 From PCCEP Portland to Everyone: I believe it was Chief Outlaw 20:15:06 From Seemab (he/him) to Everyone: It froze in a political cycle 20:15:38 From Sarah Ames, she/her, Dep City Atty to Everyone: The chat does not show up in the video. So that we have a good record of the conversation and others can participate (and we have Spanish translation), can we please make substantive comments live during the meeting? 20:15:59 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Reacted to "The chat does not sh..." with 👍🏼 20:16:03 From Ann Campbell (she,her) to Everyone: Thank you all for being here tonight. I need to leave the meeting now. 20:16:13 From PCCEP Portland to Everyone: Thank you Ann! 20:16:25 From Sameer Kanal - he/him (CSD/ABC) to Everyone: Thank you! 20:16:42 From PCCEP Portland to Everyone: Reacted to "The chat does not sh..." with 👏🏼 20:17:41 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Replying to "The chat does not sh..." I also save the chat for my notes... 20:18:30 From Natalia Ochmanek to Everyone: (I apologize i can’t speak up verbally, I’m at work tonight.) 20:18:47 From Sarah Ames, she/her, Dep City Atty to Everyone: Reacted to "(I apologize i can’t..." with 👍🏼 20:19:43 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Nice to see you Rochelle. 20:20:18 From dan handelman he/him to Everyone: “A July 2022 tip raised concerns about a $200,000 sole source contract proposed by the Community Safety Division. “ from the audit https://www.portland.gov/audit-services/news/2023/3/8/fraud-hotline-report-purchasing-problems-lead-inefficiency-and 20:20:56 From dan handelman he/him to Everyone: yes 20:22:46 From Sameer Kanal - he/him (CSD/ABC) to Everyone: Stephanie Howard is not the Community Safety Division's Director. Stephanie is a staff member of the Mayor's Office. The Director of the Community Safety Division is Community Safety Transition Director Mike Myers. The Community Safety Division is not part of the Mayor's Office, but is instead part of the Office of Management and Finance, and reports to Council as a whole. 20:23:14 From Ashley Schofield to Everyone: Thank you! 20:23:48 From Ashley Schofield to Everyone: Reacted to "(I apologize i can’t..." with 👍🏼 20:23:52 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Reacted to "Stephanie Howard is ..." with 🙌🏼 20:23:56 From Sameer Kanal - he/him (CSD/ABC) to Everyone: Reacted to "Stephanie Howard is ..." with 🙌🏼 20:23:57 From Sameer Kanal - he/him (CSD/ABC) to Everyone: Removed a 🙌🏼 reaction from "Stephanie Howard is ..." 20:25:36 From PCCEP Portland to Everyone: I believe Stephanie is saying that TrustLab was going to be brought in only to work with PPB on initial planning/prep on the bureau's end for TRC? And that there would be future consideration for other vendors for the rest of the commission? 20:26:03 From PCCEP Portland to Everyone: I'm clarifying and sharing what I heard only because it is new information to me as well 20:26:49 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Ann, did out truth & reconciliation subcommittee fizzle out? I remember it. Did it end when Theo left or when we moved under CSD? Why don't we have the Truth & Reconciliation group? 20:31:08 From dan handelman he/him to Everyone: oh I had the RE subcommittee on my calendar, why was it canceled? 20:31:22 From Natalia Ochmanek to Everyone: Overall, I would like to see the RFP for police reconciliation move forward with community involvement 20:31:47 From Natalie she/her to Everyone: Thank you 20:31:50 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Replying to "Overall, I would lik..." We got you 20:32:19 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: Thank you Celeste! 20:32:29 From Tia Palafox to Everyone: It's also spring break 20:32:34 From Natalie she/her to Everyone: thank you kindly 20:32:35 From Scott Latta to Everyone: Thanks all 20:32:46 From Barbara Bochinski Portland Copwatch to Everyone: Thanks