5.34.840 Competitive Proposals; General Procedures.

City Code Section

(Amended by Ordinances 185898 and 187373, effective October 14, 2015.)

  1. A.  General Application:  The City may utilize the RFP outlined in Subsections 5.34.840 C. through D. below for Public Improvement Contracts, allowing flexibility in both Proposal evaluation and Contract negotiation, only in accordance with ORS 279C.330 to ORS 279C.337, ORS 279C.400 to 279C.410 and Sections 5.34.800 to 5.34.890, unless other applicable statutes control the City’s use of competitive Proposals for Public Improvement Contracts.  Nothing in this rule shall limit the use of evaluation factors or other matters expressly permitted by those additional rules or authorized by ordinance.
  2. B.  Proposal Evaluation. Factors in addition to price may be considered in the selection process, but only as set forth in the RFP.  Evaluation factors need not be precise predictors of future costs and performance, but to the extent possible such evaluation factors shall: 
    1. 1.  Be reasonable estimates based on information available to the City;
    2. 2.  Treat all Proposals equitably; and
    3. 3.  Recognize that public policy requires that Public Improvements be constructed at the least overall cost to the City (see ORS 279C.305).
  3. C.   Evaluation Factors. 
    1. 1.  In basic negotiated construction contracting, where the only reason for an RFP is to consider factors other than price, those factors may consist of firm and personnel experience on similar projects, adequacy of equipment and physical plant, sources of supply, availability of key personnel, financial capacity, past performance, safety records, project understanding, proposed methods of construction, proposed milestone dates, references, service, the status of its Equal Employment Opportunity (EEO) certification, its efforts to diversify its workforce in order to reach all of the City’s citizens and other related matters that could affect the cost or quality of the Work.
    2. 2.  In CM/GC contracting, in addition to Subsection 5.33.840 D.1., those factors may also include the ability to respond to the technical complexity or unique character of the project, analyze and propose value engineering options, analyze energy efficiency measure or alternative energy options, coordinate multiple disciplines on the project, effectively utilize the time available to commence and complete the improvement, and related matters that could affect the cost or quality of the Work.
    3. 3.  In Design-Build contracting, in addition to Subsections 5.33.840 D.1. and 2., those factors may also include design professional qualifications, specialized experience, preliminary design submittals, technical merit, design-builder team experience and related matters that affect cost or quality.
  4. D.  Contract Negotiations. Contract terms may be negotiated to the extent allowed by the RFP and Sections 5.34.800 to 5.34.890, provided that the general Work Scope remains the same and that the field of competition does not change as a result of material changes to the requirements stated in the Solicitation Document. See Section 5.34.850. Terms that may be negotiated consist of details of Contract performance, methods of construction, timing, assignment of risk in specified areas, fee, and other matters that affect cost or quality. For the CM/GC Method, terms that may be negotiated also include the specific scope of pre-construction services, the work to be performed by the CM/GC, and any other term that the City has identified as being subject to negotiation.